Editor’s note: this post is a companion piece to Dave Sainte-Luce’s November 12 post on the clinic Beyond the Prison Doors: An Unexpected Lesson.
When I was accepted into the Compassionate Release and Parole Clinic, I knew I would gain valuable hands-on legal experience. I had heard about Father Frank Herrmann’s warm and supportive guidance, the direct client work, and the chance to see the criminal justice system up close. What I could not have imagined was how much the clinic would change me, both personally and professionally, and help me become a stronger, more empathetic advocate.
This semester, Father Herrmann welcomed eight students into the clinic. He paired us in teams of two and assigned each group two clients, most of whom had been incarcerated for approximately two decades and were scheduled to appear before the Parole Board this semester.
My partner Elizabeth and I were assigned two clients incarcerated at different medium-security correctional facilities. Our primary responsibility was to prepare our clients for their upcoming parole hearings. This involved meeting with them in person at the correctional institutions, participating in Zoom calls, preparing different kinds of documentation, communicating regularly through the Massachusetts Department of Correction’s messaging system, and supporting them during their hearings before the Parole Board.
Prior to this clinic, I had never stepped foot inside a jail or prison. My understanding of correctional institutions came primarily from what I had seen in the media. I remember how unfamiliar and intimidating the environment felt during my first visit. Even getting into the visiting room was a challenge. Elizabeth and I made our fair share of mistakes as we tried to figure out what we were allowed to wear, what we could bring inside, and how to establish that we were authorized to enter as student attorneys representing our client.
Once we eventually made it into an attorney meeting room within the prison’s visiting area that first time, I felt completely in over my head. I was meeting with a real client who was relying on me, a 2L, to help represent him at one of the most important hearings of his life. At first, it felt uncomfortable to be leading the conversation, asking questions, and providing legal guidance. But as the meeting progressed, the conversation began to flow naturally. I realized that I knew more than I had given myself credit for and that I was capable of providing meaningful assistance.
That first meeting was one of the most grounding moments of my law school experience. I walked into the prison questioning whether I was prepared to take on the responsibility of representing someone, and I walked out feeling that I had taken a meaningful step toward becoming the lawyer I hope to be. Since then, each meeting has helped me grow more confident in my abilities, but more importantly, has allowed me to understand the importance of empathetic advocacy.
Sitting across from my clients and hearing about their lives before and during their incarceration, as well as their hopes for the future, has made me truly understand the importance of the work in our clinic. While this is only one small part of my law school experience, the outcomes of my clients’ parole hearings could change their entire lives. That understanding has made every meeting, conversation, and preparation session feel significant. It is both humbling and rewarding to know that, even as student attorneys, we have the opportunity to make a meaningful difference in someone’s future. There is something incredibly fulfilling about putting the skills we have spent time developing toward a cause that matters so deeply to another person.
What has made this experience even more meaningful is the gratitude our clients and their loved ones have shown us throughout the process. Our clients have frequently expressed how thankful they are for the time and effort we put into preparing for their hearings, and their family and friends have been equally appreciative. For our clients and their families, these hearings represent the possibility of finally being reunited after decades apart. Knowing how much hope they have placed in this process has made us even more determined to advocate for them to the best of our abilities.
Beyond the direct client work, our weekly seminar with Father Herrmann has been another highlight of the experience. Each week, we have the opportunity to share updates on our clients, discuss challenges, and ask one another for advice. Although we each represent different individuals with unique cases, the clinic truly feels like a collective effort. We learn from one another’s experiences, offer different perspectives, and work together to determine how we can best advocate for our clients. Father Herrmann fosters an environment of open discussion and thoughtful problem-solving where everyone feels comfortable asking questions and seeking guidance. His encouragement and support have been invaluable throughout the semester, especially as we navigate the challenges of representing clients for the first time.
I have been equally inspired by being surrounded by classmates who are just as passionate about their clients and committed to helping them succeed. Hearing about the progress others have made, the challenges they have encountered, and the relationships they have developed with their clients has been one of my favorite parts of the seminar. There is a genuine sense that everyone is rooting for one another’s clients, and that shared commitment has made the experience even more special.
Although I am only a 2L, this clinic has easily been the most meaningful experience of my law school career. I entered hoping to gain practical legal skills, but I have gained something far more valuable: a deeper understanding of the responsibility of being an attorney, the power of client advocacy, and the difference that compassionate representation can make. Most importantly, this clinic has shown me that being a lawyer is not simply about knowing the law; it is about using that knowledge to support others during some of the most consequential moments of their lives. The opportunity to be that person for my clients has been incredibly rewarding, and it has reminded me why I wanted to pursue a career in law in the first place. I cannot recommend this experience enough to other BC Law students.
Rebecca Carcieri is a second-year student at BC Law. Contact her at carcierr@bc.edu.