Supreme Court Questions Broadband Provider Liability for User Misconduct

This guest post by BC Law Professor and Associate Dean of Academic Affairs Daniel Lyons first appeared in the AEIdeas Blog.

Intermediary liability—when a company should be liable for users’ misuse of its product by users—has been a long-standing issue in tech policy. Two years ago, the Supreme Court dismissed a case alleging Twitter aided and abetted terrorism by allowing ISIS to recruit on its platform. This week, the Court weighed in again, hearing argument in a case involving a billion-dollar judgment against broadband provider Cox Communications for failing to terminate accounts suspected of copyright infringement. The case raises significant questions about copyright enforceability, broadband providers’ role as gateways to the internet, and digital equity concerns. The justices seemed doubtful that notification of user misuse was sufficient to trigger liability, although they struggled to find an alternative that balanced the equities of the case.

Continue reading

AI Art and Copyright Law

AI has taken the world by storm, and a plethora of new legal questions have come along with it. Issues relating to AI have only just begun to make their way to the courts, so it may be a while before we have concrete answers, but that doesn’t mean we can’t consider the implications in the meantime.

AI was the central topic of Ropes & Gray’s 6th Annual International IP Summit at BC Law’s campus last month. While the functions AI can serve are almost too many to discuss, one especially interesting application of AI is to generate art. The song “Heart on My Sleeve” used AI to emulate the voices and styles of Drake and The Weeknd with eerie accuracy, and the photo that took first place the Sony World Photography Awards was later revealed to be the product of AI. 

“The Electrician,” created by Boris Eldagsen using AI, which took first place at the Sony World Photography Awards

The popularity of AI-generated art is already having an impact on copyright law. I had a chance to speak with Joseph Liu, accredited scholar and copyright professor here at BC Law, to break down some of the problems posed by AI in the copyright space. 

Continue reading